Is the warehouse club worth it? Work it out from your receipts

A warehouse club charges you a yearly fee just to walk in the door, and then sells you enormous packs of things at prices that look very good on the shelf. Whether the fee comes back to you depends entirely on what you buy there, and on what you would have paid for the same things elsewhere. We were members for years without ever checking. When we finally sat down with a year of receipts, the answer was closer than we expected, and it changed how we shop there.

What a club is genuinely good at

Big packs of things that keep. Paper towels, rice, coffee, oats, dish soap, the bags of frozen vegetables that live at the bottom of the freezer. If your household gets through a thing every month and it does not go off, a larger pack at a lower price per ounce is a real saving, and it is the same saving every single month. For a family that eats a lot of rice, that one item can cover a good part of the fee on its own.

What a club is quietly bad at

Three things, and each one hides in plain sight until you look at the receipts.

• Things that go off. A pack of salad greens three times the size of the usual one is cheaper by the ounce and dearer in practice if a third of it goes in the bin. Fresh food is where the club arithmetic breaks down most often, and it is where we found our worst numbers.
• The trip itself. A club is usually further away than the supermarket, and driving out there for three items costs more in time and fuel than the three items save. The saving only shows up when the trip is a big one.
• The things you did not go in for. A club is laid out to put them in front of you, and it is very good at its job. A set of storage boxes at a good price is still money spent on storage boxes you did not know you needed until you saw them.

How to do the sum yourself

You need the last few months of receipts from the club and from wherever else you shop. A shoebox will do. Then there are four steps, and the order matters.

1. Compare by the ounce, never by the pack. A club pack and a supermarket pack are different sizes, sometimes wildly so. The price of a single ounce, or a single roll, is the only number that lines up across the two.
2. Count only the things you buy at both. A thing you buy only at the club has nothing to be compared with. It might still be a good price. You simply cannot tell from your own receipts. Leave it out of the sum.
3. Add up the difference. For each of those things, take the club price per ounce against your usual price per ounce elsewhere, and multiply by how much you actually bought at the club. Some items will come out negative, where the supermarket was cheaper, and they count too.
4. Subtract the fee. What is left is what the membership earned you this year. If the number is negative, the fee was the most expensive thing you bought there.

What we found

The saving was real on a short list of staples and imaginary on almost everything else. Rice, coffee, paper goods and cleaning things carried the membership. Fresh produce and the snacks that came home in a moment of weakness cost us more than they would have at the supermarket, once we counted what got thrown away. On balance the fee came back, but not by the margin we had assumed, and we now go there with a shorter list and walk past the middle of the store.

Whether your own household comes out ahead depends on how much of that short list of staples you get through. A family that buys the same twenty things every month often does well. A household of one that visits four times a year often does not, and the honest thing is to check.

Letting the app do the sum

ManyStops keeps every price you record along with the size of the pack, which is what makes the comparison possible. For a store on its list of warehouse clubs it adds the sum up for you, on that store's own page. It compares only the items you have bought both there and somewhere else, by the ounce, over the last year, and it tells you how the total stands against the membership fee. It stays silent until it has enough pairs to say anything honest, because a verdict from two jars of peanut butter would be a coincidence dressed up as a fact.

All of that comes from what you paid and nothing else. The club's own prices are the club's business. Whether the membership is worth it is yours.

Read next: Which shopping list apps learn your store, and what that means